Pre-Grant Publication Number: 20070118712
Please help the USPTO examine the application by evaluating the relevance of the publicly submitted prior art to the patent application.
Peer To Patent forwards the Top 10 most relevant prior art submissions and their annotations to the USPTO.
Review this prior art and click on the thumbs up (or down) to indicate whether this submission should be forwarded to the USPTO.
If you login then you can add an annotation by typing in the box at the bottom of the screen to comment on the relevance of the prior art to the claims of the patent application.
Review this prior art and click on the thumbs up (or down) to indicate whether this submission should be forwarded to the USPTO.
If you login then you can add an annotation by typing in the box at the bottom of the screen to comment on the relevance of the prior art to the claims of the patent application.

Prior Art Detail
Summary / Description
| Summary / Description | An arguement that software patents cannot be granted as by default they constitute prior art. |
Basic Information
| Type of Prior Art | Online Publication |
| URL | http://deepthought.newsvine.com... |
| Author/Creator | Deep_Thought |
| Title | Software Patents - A Modern Fool's Gold? |
| Publication Date | July 11, 2005 |
| Publisher | NewsVine |
| Directions to Document Location | |
| Additional Information | |
Notes / To Do
| Notes | |
Excerpt
Excerpt In this article I intend to demonstrate that software patents are not only worthless, but that they could amount to infringement of hardware patents and intellectual property in the public domain. For the tech savvy and the legal beagles, this should prove to be a highly thought provoking article. |
Relevance
Claims
1
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
2
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
3
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
4
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
5
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
6
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
7
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
8
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
9
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
10
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
11
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
12
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
13
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
14
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
15
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
16
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
17
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
18
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
19
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
20
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
21
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
22
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
23
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
24
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
25
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
26
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
27
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
28
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
29
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
30
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
31
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
32
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
33
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
34
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
35
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
36
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
37
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
38
Relevance
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
The article claims that this is both a function of the hardware and that software is not 'novel' as it creation can be brute forced by an automated process.
Claim Chart
All
0 days left








