Pre-Grant Publication Number: 20070255832
Please help the USPTO examine the application by evaluating the relevance of the publicly submitted prior art to the patent application.
Peer To Patent forwards the Top 10 most relevant prior art submissions and their annotations to the USPTO.
Review this prior art and click on the thumbs up (or down) to indicate whether this submission should be forwarded to the USPTO.
If you login then you can add an annotation by typing in the box at the bottom of the screen to comment on the relevance of the prior art to the claims of the patent application.
Review this prior art and click on the thumbs up (or down) to indicate whether this submission should be forwarded to the USPTO.
If you login then you can add an annotation by typing in the box at the bottom of the screen to comment on the relevance of the prior art to the claims of the patent application.
Prior Art Detail
Summary / Description
| Summary / Description | The method involves connecting the device to a port of a switch, transmitting an identity of the port from the switch to the device using a neighborhood detection protocol, transmitting the identifier of the port from the device to an address server and allocating the Internet Protocol address to the device based on the identity of the port. |
Basic Information
| Type of Prior Art | Issued Patents - US |
| Country | United States of America |
| Patent/Application # | US 2005/0163118 A1 |
| Kind Code | United States (US) - Patent Appl. Publ. within the ... - A1 |
| Patentee Name | Siemens |
| Relevant Pages, Columns, or Lines | Paragraph 0013 |
| URL | |
| Filing Date | July 28, 2005 |
| Additional Information | |
Notes / To Do
| Notes | |
Excerpt
Excerpt [0013]
This is particularly advantageous for applications in automation engineering, in particular for Industrial Ethernet and Realtime Ethernet. In particular, the invention allows efficient network management of Ethernet applications in the industrial sector, where said applications often feature a great number of nodes.
|
Relevance
Claims
1
Relevance
Inventive step:
Claim 1 differs from the cited prior art solely by non-functional descriptive material (in a windfarm). Since it is rather unrelevant if the network is used in a windfarm or not, and no wind turbine related problems are to challenge within this application, there is no proper reason for granting this application. All means are known to public, and the usage of a common network design in a new technical field is just to be seen as inventive, if new problems related to the new usage are solved.
I.e.: In paragraph 0013 of the prior art it is quoted, that the application of the technique to a known and huge industrial Ethernet LANs is quite advantagous. A windfarm can be seen as such a big industrial LAN. This specification - to use the content of the prior art in a windfarm network - is obvious for a person skilled in the art.
Even paragrah 0013 in the present application says: " ... over the network so that the IP address of a component connected to the network is unambiguously associated with a specified wind turbine of the windfarm by ..."
I want to put the focus on the expression "component connected to the network": This shows that there is just a COMPONENT - which is a computer - connected to the network, and it's irrelevant wether there is a wind turbine or a refrigerator connected to said component.
Inventive step:
Claim 1 differs from the cited prior art solely by non-functional descriptive material (in a windfarm). Since it is rather unrelevant if the network is used in a windfarm or not, and no wind turbine related problems are to challenge within this application, there is no proper reason for granting this application. All means are known to public, and the usage of a common network design in a new technical field is just to be seen as inventive, if new problems related to the new usage are solved.
I.e.: In paragraph 0013 of the prior art it is quoted, that the application of the technique to a known and huge industrial Ethernet LANs is quite advantagous. A windfarm can be seen as such a big industrial LAN. This specification - to use the content of the prior art in a windfarm network - is obvious for a person skilled in the art.
Even paragrah 0013 in the present application says: " ... over the network so that the IP address of a component connected to the network is unambiguously associated with a specified wind turbine of the windfarm by ..."
I want to put the focus on the expression "component connected to the network": This shows that there is just a COMPONENT - which is a computer - connected to the network, and it's irrelevant wether there is a wind turbine or a refrigerator connected to said component.
Claim Chart
All
8
Relevance
Inventive step:
Since d) and e) is almost identical to claim 1, a), b), c) is considerd to be inventive.
Inventive step:
Since d) and e) is almost identical to claim 1, a), b), c) is considerd to be inventive.
Claim Chart
All
