Pre-Grant Publication Number: 20070255832
Collaborate on the process of community review for this application. Posting will not be forwarded to the USPTO. Flagging a post as an ACTION ITEM signals further research. Flagging SPAM and ABUSE helps to manage discussion. Placing double brackets around a reference to a claim or prior art will create a hyperlink to the original ex. [[claim 1]] and [[prior art 2]].

Please review the Community Code of Conduct prior to posting

Discussion (21)
  Facilitator's Comment     Action Item
  Show without Noise
CLAIM 00001

<claim-text> A method for automatically configuring a local network in a windfarm, comprising the steps of <claim-text>(a) automatically assigning an IP address to a device connected to said local windfarm network, </claim-text><claim-text>(b) automatically receiving an identifier tag from said device, and </claim-text><claim-text>(c) relating the automatically assigned IP address of the device to a specific wind turbine in the windfarm which is identified by said identifier tag. </claim-text></claim-text>

Comments
Fulton Wilcox (6 months ago)
Regarding Claim 00001 There is no evident novelty to this claim. Indeed, if from a standards perspective, the devices involved conformed to widespread ethernet and related standards, the claims described would in effect be "out of the box" capabilities. As an example of long-existing state of the art:, "When a customer
plugs in a device, the ESLAM reports the customer's device MAC when it
sees it. The DHCP server records the MAC <=> IP binding." http://www.ieee802.org/3/efm/public/email/msg00516.html . Although the patent descriotion rejects the relevance of DHCP because of its use of an IP address "lease" mechanism, in fact DHCP permirs very long leases as wee as enabling client devices to renew leases. It therefore appears that this claim represents a non-standard recreation of long existing standards based handshakes and inventory methods found in ethernet networks (and probably some predecessor environments such as SNA.
more...

CLAIM 00002

<claim-text> The method according to <claim-ref idref='CLM-00001'>claim 1</claim-ref>, wherein the identifier tag is the number or name of the specific wind turbine comprising said device. </claim-text>

Comments
Fulton Wilcox (6 months ago)
Regarding Claim 00002 In the ethernet and other standards-based netoworking world, this "tag" is known as the MAC address, and there are billions of them in operation. more...

CLAIM 00003

<claim-text> The method according to <claim-ref idref='CLM-00001'>claim 1</claim-ref>, wherein the device sends the identifier tag on request. </claim-text>

Comments
Fulton Wilcox (6 months ago)
Regarding Claim 00003 The capability to receive a polling command and to respond with appropriate data is inherent to any "managed object." At the network physical layer, the MAC (media access control") device plays this managed object rolle. THE MAC-IP address relationship is fundamental to the client-seber relationship described in this claim, and it qualifies as rather ancient state of the art. http://www.faqs.org/rfcs/rfc2358.html more...

CLAIM 00004

<claim-text> The method according to <claim-ref idref='CLM-00001'>claim 1</claim-ref>, wherein the IP address is permanently assigned in step (a). </claim-text>

Comments
Fulton Wilcox (6 months ago)
Regarding Claim 00004: There is nothing new about static IP addresses. Essentially, this patent application does not purport to offer any new claims regarding static IP addresses, ecept that under different claims asserts that it sets them up faster. more...

CLAIM 00005

<claim-text> The method according to <claim-ref idref='CLM-00001'>claim 1</claim-ref>, wherein the IP address is dynamically assigned in step (a). </claim-text>

Comments
Fulton Wilcox (6 months ago)
Regarding Claim 00005 This claim essentially covers the same ground as DHCP, which dynamically "leases" IP addressees." The DHCP process can be used to support essentially static IP addresses by extending the lease time or by supporting client renewal of IP address. In any case, DHCP addressed can also be mapped to MAC addresses, obviating the need for static IP addresses. more...

CLAIM 00008

<claim-text> A method for automatic setup of a local network in a windfarm, comprising the steps of <claim-text>(a) automatically allocating IP addresses to a plurality of devices connected to said local windfarm network, </claim-text><claim-text>(b) automatically discovering a topology of said local windfarm network, </claim-text><claim-text>(c) automatically identifying at least one wind turbine subnetwork, </claim-text><claim-text>(d) receiving an identifier tag for said at least one wind turbine subnetwork, and </claim-text><claim-text>(e) relating the automatically allocated IP addresses of the devices comprised in that at least one wind turbine subnetwork to the wind turbine identified by said identifier tag. </claim-text></claim-text>

Comments
Fulton Wilcox (6 months ago)
Regarding Claim 00008Again, these are steps normally used to set up a DHCP IP address assignment proces. There are many tools to associate IP address and MAC and other address data - e.g., see http://manageengine.adventnet.com/products/oputils/address-monitoring-tools.html

As noted above, addresses assigned by DHCP can be made either very long lived or permanent.
more...

CLAIM 00014

<claim-text> The method according to <claim-ref idref='CLM-00008'>claim 8</claim-ref>, wherein the step of discovering the topology of the network includes also the detection of the device numbers of the discovered devices. </claim-text>

Comments
Fulton Wilcox (6 months ago)
Regarding Claim 00014 As noted above, there is a lot of prior art in the network asset management world, centered on MIBs that can do what is described and much more, depending on the managed device's function and level of intelligence. more...